Introducing the Inaugural SeeMe Index for Beauty – a comprehensive assessment of the top 40 US beauty brands’* consumer-facing inclusivity efforts.
At SeeMe Index, we measure the inclusive efforts of top brands in each industry, scoring brands on 3 key components** (ads, product, DEI commitments) across 6 identity dimensions (gender expression, skin tone, age, observed sexual orientation, body size, and visible disability).
Together this data comprises each brand’s Inclusive Quotient or IQ score. IQ scores translate into 4 brand segments***: Certified Inclusive for the most inclusive brands, followed by the segments of Acts Inclusive, Feels Inclusive and Thinks Inclusive, respectively.
For those seeking in-depth industry insights and brand scores, custom reports and consulting services are available.
Custom reports include insights like these customized to your industry, category and competitors:
- Colorism continues: Did you know you lose 1 sec of screen time for each deeper skin tone? The lightest skin tone has 4x more screen time than the darkest.
- Lack of Testing Transparency: Only 25% of brands provide detail on who was in the product testing group. Details like age, skin tone and gender expression give consumers confidence the product will work for them.
We are committed to updating the index annually and expanding coverage to more industries.
Index Scores
Certified Inclusive
M•A•C
DOVE
L'OREAL PARIS
NYX COSMETICS
MAYBELLINE
FENTY BEAUTY & FENTY SKIN
ELF
Acts Inclusive
ESTÉE LAUDER
YSL BEAUTY
OLAY
VASELINE
LANCÔME
FARMACY BEAUTY
CLINIQUE
CERAVE
BENEFIT COSMETICS
PANTENE
MAKE UP FOR EVER
Feels Inclusive
OUAI
LA ROCHE-POSAY
CHARLOTTE TILBURY BEAUTY
BOBBI BROWN
ANASTASIA BEVERLY HILLS
NARS COSMETICS
SKINCEUTICALS
AVEENO
GARNIER
KOSAS
TATCHA
FIRST AID BEAUTY
NEUTROGENA
LA MER
CHANEL BEAUTY
Thinks Inclusive
GIVENCHY BEAUTY
OGX
COLOURPOP COSMETICS
COVERGIRL
DIOR BEAUTY
KYLIE COSMETICS
SK-II
*We determined the top 40 beauty brands utilizing a combination of sales data and industry resources. For sales data, we assessed the rankings of top beauty brands using Circana data for 52 weeks ending June 30th, 2023. For industry sources, we consulted the following resources to ensure we represented the most powerful brands in the industry including WWD Inc 45 Most Powerful Brands in Beauty, WWD Top 100 Beauty Manufacturers, Tribe Dynamics and Spate.
**3 Components: Each component carries equal weight in determining a brand's final Inclusive Quotient, or IQ score.
- Public Assets: We analyzed each brand’s most viewed and widely watched content across platforms like Meta ads, Instagram, YouTube, and TikTok. Our analysis primarily covered assets from January 1, 2023 to June 30th, 2023. However, if at least 10 assets with view counts exceeding 20,000 were unavailable, we expanded our timeframe up to a year. We prioritized most-viewed assets, allowing us to gain valuable insight into media investment and virality.
- Product line: We evaluated each brand's product line, considering everything from products and shades to copy and website features. Our scoring system was normalized to be fair and equitable across the unique characteristics of different beauty categories. For example, shades were not reviewed for skincare-only brands and hair-related assessments were not reviewed for non-haircare brands.
- External DEI Commitments: We examined external Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) commitments made by each brand. This encompassed commitments undertaken through company-led initiatives, partnerships, donations, and public announcements.
***Inclusive Quotient (IQ) scores organizes brands into four distinct segments:
- Certified Inclusive: I am empathetic and a proven inclusive brand.
Brands in this category are at the forefront of inclusivity. They excel across ads, product and DEI commitments, demonstrating holistic inclusivity efforts. Their efforts are often ingrained in the DNA of the brand itself. These brands are certified inclusive and have earned the prestigious SeeMe seal of approval, which they can proudly showcase in their marketing materials. - Acts Inclusive: I stand with you and support you.
These brands are actively working toward inclusivity and have made significant progress. While they might not excel in all three components, they consistently show a strong dedication to inclusivity. - Feels Inclusive: I try to feel what you feel.
These brands are taking some meaningful inclusive actions but it is inconsistent across components and identities. They are more nascent in their inclusivity journey but deliver some impactful efforts. - Thinks inclusive: I try to think like you do.
Brands in this category show promise of inclusive action. However, efforts have yet to fully materialize, and they have significant room for improvement.